Main Content

Zittrain Torts Playlist Spring 2013

Bryne v. Boadle

Should courts be willing to presume negligence in situations where the plaintiff's injury implies negligence has occurred? A barrel of flour rolls from the window of defendant’s shop and flattens the plaintiff, who was on the sidewalk below. Defendant admitted he was a dealer in flour. However, none of the witnesses saw anyone nearby who could have been responsible for the falling barrel. Neither was the plaintiff able to produce any evidence to support a claim of negligence.