Main Content

Zittrain Torts Playlist Spring 2018

People Express Airlines, Inc., Plaintiff-Respondent, v. Consolidated Rail Corporation, A New Jersey Corporation; BASF Wyandotte Company, A New Jersey Corporation; and Union Tank Car Company, A Delaware Corporation, Defendants-Appellants.

"The Evacuated Airport"

Should courts support a negligence cause of action where the injury is purely economic? If so, how far should courts extend the boundaries of the negligent actor's liability?

The defendants' negligence led to the risk of a tank car exploding. The business operations of plaintiff's airline--which was within a one-mile radius of the tank car--was interrupted due to a forced evacuation by municipal authorities. Ultimately, no explosion resulted and there was no property damage suffered by the plaintiff. However, plaintiff sued the defendants on the theory that their negligence resulted in economic loss due to the disruption of plaintiff's business activities.