10 State Attorneys General Relationship with Federal Government: Mar. 23, 2026 10 State Attorneys General Relationship with Federal Government: Mar. 23, 2026
10.1 Introduction and Speaker 10.1 Introduction and Speaker
This week we'll be joined for the first 20 minutes on zoom by Caroline VanZile, the DC Solicitor General (SG). After graduating from Yale, she clerked for Judge Boasberg, then Judge Kavanaugh, and Justice Kennedy, and was an associate at Skadden before turning to public service. Come prepared with questions.
State AGs have a complex relationship with the federal government, including the President, the U.S. Department of Justice, local U.S. Attorneys, and other federal agencies. Away from the headlines, in most cases, attorneys general cooperate with federal agencies to carry out federal policy, but in some cases and in some states, attorneys general attempt to either challenge or prompt federal action.
The differing strains of this relationship do not necessarily divide on the usual partisan axis. Over the years, the relationship has been characterized by cooperation, disinterest, preemption, or outright hostility, some times even within the same Administration.
10.2 History of Conflict – Inaction v. Preemption 10.2 History of Conflict – Inaction v. Preemption
10.2.1. Obama Preemption Executive Order (May 20, 2009)
10.2.2. After Scaling Back Student Loan Regulations, Administration Tries to Stop State Efforts, N.Y. Times (Sept. 6, 2018)
10.2.3. 39 State AGs Announce $1.85 Billion Settlement with Navient (Jan. 22, 2022)
10.2.4. 23 AGs Oppose FCC's Possible AI Law Preemption, Law360 (Dec. 19, 2025)
10.3 State and Federal Cooperation and Non-Cooperation 10.3 State and Federal Cooperation and Non-Cooperation
10.3.1. OH AG Joins FTC, Other States in Sweep to Squash Illegal Robocalls, OH AG website (July 18, 2023)
10.3.2. With Disputed Legal Maneuver, Trump Tries to Set Policy Without Legislation, N.Y. Times (Mar. 12, 2026)
10.3.3. States Motion to Intervene in HPE-Juniper Antitrust Settlement, N.D. Cal. (Oct. 14, 2025)
10.3.4. States To Head Live Nation Antitrust Trial After Feds Settle, Law360 (Mar. 13, 2026)
10.3.5. The Threats and Bare-Knuckle Tactics of MAGA’s Top Antitrust Fixer, Wall St. Journal (Mar. 20, 2026)
10.4 States sue President 10.4 States sue President
10.4.1. Texas vs. the Feds - A Look at the Lawsuits, Texas Tribune (Jan. 11, 2017)