Main Content

Main Content

Zittrain Torts Playlist Spring 2013

Fred Brosnahan, Appellant, v. Western Air Lines, Inc., and Delta Airlines, Inc., Appellees.

Headnote

Defendant airlines failed to supervise and assist a passenger stowing his carry-on luggage in an overhead compartment. Consequently, the passenger dropped his bag on plaintiff’s head. Some courts hold that defendants will not be liable if their negligence merely creates a “condition” which makes it possible for an accident to occur. In this case, the court considers this distinction against the backdrop of the special relationship between the airlines and its passengers.